Convert_SP_to_TVF

Posted onAuthorStormAdminLeave a comment

Snippet Name: Convert_SP_to_TVF

Tags:

Created Date: 2025-06-16 13:12:45
Last Modified Date: 2025-05-31 10:31:39

Dependencies:

DBA Notes:

Sample Output: 

Title: Convert SP to TVF
Author: user
I have this SQL Server stored procedure which queries Active Directory via a linked server named ADSI. can it be changed to a table function instead? --EXECUTE dbo.usp_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory 'izaguirrel'
CREATE OR ALTER PROCEDURE usp_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory(@SamAccountName VARCHAR(128))
AS
BEGIN
DECLARE @cmd VARCHAR(MAX)
SET @cmd = 
'SELECT displayName, telephoneNumber, sAMAccountName,
mail, mobile, department, physicalDeliveryOfficeName, sn,givenname
FROM ''LDAP://us1.autonation.com/DC=us1,DC=autonation,DC=com''
WHERE objectClass = ''User''
AND sAMAccountName = ''' + @SamAccountName + '''
'

EXECUTE (@cmd) AT ADSI
END
GO

Author: ChatGPT
Yes, you can convert this stored procedure into a table-valued function (TVF). The main change involves altering the `EXECUTE` command to return a table from the function. Here???s how you can do it:

```sql
CREATE OR ALTER FUNCTION dbo.ufn_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory (@SamAccountName VARCHAR(128))
RETURNS TABLE
AS
RETURN
(
    SELECT displayName, telephoneNumber, sAMAccountName,
           mail, mobile, department, physicalDeliveryOfficeName, sn, givenname
    FROM OPENQUERY(
        ADSI,
        'SELECT displayName, telephoneNumber, sAMAccountName,
                mail, mobile, department, physicalDeliveryOfficeName, sn, givenname
         FROM ''LDAP://us1.autonation.com/DC=us1,DC=autonation,DC=com''
         WHERE objectClass = ''User''
         AND sAMAccountName = ''' + @SamAccountName + ''''
    )
);
GO
```

### Explanation:
1. **Function Definition**: The function is defined using `CREATE OR ALTER FUNCTION` and specifies a return type of `TABLE`.
2. **OPENQUERY**: This function uses `OPENQUERY` to execute the LDAP query against the linked server `ADSI`.
3. **Query**: The LDAP query is constructed inside the `OPENQUERY` call. This query retrieves the desired attributes for the given `sAMAccountName`.

### Usage:
You can use this table-valued function like a table in your `SELECT` statements. For example:

```sql
SELECT *
FROM dbo.ufn_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory('izaguirrel');
```

This approach allows you to call the function within other queries and join it with other tables as needed.

Author: user
i believe the OPENQUERY expects a string for the query parameter, and does nto allow concatenation of the desired value i get an error Msg 102, Level 15, State 1, Procedure fn_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory, Line 15 [Batch Start Line 30]
Incorrect syntax near '+'.


Author: ChatGPT
You're right. `OPENQUERY` requires the query to be a static string and doesn't support string concatenation within the call. To work around this, you can use dynamic SQL within the function. However, SQL Server does not support dynamic SQL directly within a table-valued function. Instead, you can use a multi-statement table-valued function (MSTVF) with dynamic SQL and insert the results into a table variable.

Here's an updated version using MSTVF:

```sql
CREATE OR ALTER FUNCTION dbo.ufn_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory (@SamAccountName VARCHAR(128))
RETURNS @UserInfo TABLE
(
    displayName NVARCHAR(256),
    telephoneNumber NVARCHAR(50),
    sAMAccountName NVARCHAR(128),
    mail NVARCHAR(256),
    mobile NVARCHAR(50),
    department NVARCHAR(128),
    physicalDeliveryOfficeName NVARCHAR(128),
    sn NVARCHAR(128),
    givenname NVARCHAR(128)
)
AS
BEGIN
    DECLARE @cmd VARCHAR(MAX)

    SET @cmd = 
    'SELECT displayName, telephoneNumber, sAMAccountName,
            mail, mobile, department, physicalDeliveryOfficeName, sn, givenname
     FROM OPENQUERY(
         ADSI,
         ''SELECT displayName, telephoneNumber, sAMAccountName,
                mail, mobile, department, physicalDeliveryOfficeName, sn, givenname
          FROM ''''LDAP://us1.autonation.com/DC=us1,DC=autonation,DC=com''''
          WHERE objectClass = ''''User''''
          AND sAMAccountName = ''''' + @SamAccountName + '''''''
     )'

    INSERT INTO @UserInfo
    EXEC (@cmd)

    RETURN
END
GO
```

### Explanation:
1. **Function Definition**: The function is defined using `CREATE OR ALTER FUNCTION` and specifies a return type of `TABLE`.
2. **Return Table Variable**: A table variable `@UserInfo` is declared to store the results.
3. **Dynamic SQL**: The query is constructed as a dynamic SQL string, which includes the concatenation of the `@SamAccountName` parameter.
4. **INSERT INTO**: The results of the dynamic SQL execution are inserted into the table variable.
5. **Return**: The function returns the table variable.

### Usage:
You can use this table-valued function like a table in your `SELECT` statements:

```sql
SELECT *
FROM dbo.ufn_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory('izaguirrel');
```

This solution allows for the dynamic query to be executed and the results to be returned as a table.

Author: user
now i get the error "Msg 443, Level 16, State 14, Procedure fn_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory, Line 32 [Batch Start Line 29]
Invalid use of a side-effecting operator 'INSERT EXEC' within a function."

Author: ChatGPT
In SQL Server, you cannot use `INSERT EXEC` within a function because it's considered a side-effecting operation. To achieve similar functionality, you should use a stored procedure or consider another approach, such as using a view with dynamic SQL.

Since using a table-valued function directly for dynamic queries is not feasible, one alternative is to use a stored procedure that returns a result set. If you must use a table-valued function, the dynamic SQL needs to be handled outside the function, which might not be possible without a stored procedure.

Here is how you can use a stored procedure instead:

### Stored Procedure Approach
```sql
CREATE OR ALTER PROCEDURE dbo.usp_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory
    @SamAccountName VARCHAR(128)
AS
BEGIN
    DECLARE @cmd VARCHAR(MAX)

    SET @cmd = 
    'SELECT displayName, telephoneNumber, sAMAccountName,
            mail, mobile, department, physicalDeliveryOfficeName, sn, givenname
     FROM OPENQUERY(
         ADSI,
         ''SELECT displayName, telephoneNumber, sAMAccountName,
                mail, mobile, department, physicalDeliveryOfficeName, sn, givenname
          FROM ''''LDAP://us1.autonation.com/DC=us1,DC=autonation,DC=com''''
          WHERE objectClass = ''''User''''
          AND sAMAccountName = ''''' + @SamAccountName + '''''''
     )'

    EXEC (@cmd)
END
GO
```

### Usage:
```sql
EXEC dbo.usp_GetUserInfoFromActiveDirectory 'izaguirrel';
```

If you need to incorporate this within another query, you can use temporary tables or table variables to store the result set from the stored procedure.

### Using a View
If the query is fixed and the parameters can be passed in a more static way, you could create a view to access the LDAP information, but this would not allow for parameterization in the same way.

### Conclusion
Given the constraints, the most practical solution is to use a stored procedure to handle dynamic SQL. If you need to use the result set within a larger query, you can call the stored procedure, store the results in a temporary table, and then use that temporary table in your queries.

Leave a Reply